Uncategorized

Eight (8) Measures the Government may consider before lifting the cap on interest rates.

By September 18, 2017 No Comments

It has not come as a surprise that Dr. Njoroge, the Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) Governor has indicated that the CBK intends to push for the abolishment of the interest rate cap law. When the Banking Act was amended to cap the interest rates at 4% points above the CBK rate, (which currently stands at 10%), a false senses of relief among borrowers spread far and wide.

Immediately after the amendment most borrowers benefited as their existing loans were re-priced to reflect the new rates.  Lenders had their margins squeezed and resorted to cutting costs and increasing efficiency which was occasioned by massive staff laying offs by major banks and the increased adoption of technology through mobile and internet banking.  However, the laws of economics were bound to catch up with this amendments in the long run.

In any economy, the banks acts as intermediaries through which people deposit funds and get loans. Therefore, banks get their profits from the difference between the rate at which they pay depositors and the rate at which they charge borrowers.  These rates are determined by among other factors:

  1. Market forces i.e. demand and supply
  2. Government regulation through monetary policies that affect the pricing of loans and deposits.
  3. Information flow where incase the bank lacks information about the borrower’s credit worth, they raise the rates to cover the risks involved. From the consumers’ perspective, lack of information on competitors’ rates will lead to banks taking advantage of this and offering higher rates.
  4. Credit risk where the risk of loss due to the unwillingness of the borrower to meet his payment obligations promotes the banks to price their loans higher to cater for this risk.
  5. Distribution of market power occasioned by the number of banks i.e. in a market controlled by few banks, there tends to be a lower consumer bargaining power in turn leading to higher interest rates.

Because the cap on interest rates ignored these factors, the results were bound to be negative in the long run. Any section of the society whose expected default rate is near the maximum spread were either unable to access credit from the banks or paid exorbitant fees to have their loans processed.  Since interest spreads (the difference between interest you pay for deposit and what you charge for loans) were capped, risky products such as unsecured loans to small business enterprises disappeared. There was also a notable increase in the fees and charges for loans processing for the risky borrower.

The most hurt were the new borrowers with low credit ratings and no security. Minutes from a CBK’s Monetary Policy Committee meeting suggested that small and medium enterprises had been disproportionately affected. This is believed to be a consequence of rigid credit standards, with banks leaning towards lending to safer borrowers, such as the government or large corporations rather than small riskier borrowers.

Learning from what followed from the amendment of Banking Act 2016, the government should enact more effective measures of reducing interest rates on loans over the long run and of improving access to finance such as:

  1. Promoting measures that enhance competition and product innovation in the banking sector;
  2. Improving financial consumer protection frameworks;
  3. Increasing financial literacy among the citizens;
  4. Promoting credit bureaus and putting in place measures to enhance credit information sharing, Expand credit information sharing mechanism to include most of the credit providers such as small scale lenders and mobile money transfer service providers;
  5. Enforcing disclosure of interest rates so that it becomes easier for consumers to make a choice and enhance transparency in loan pricing;
  6. Full implementation of all the structural and policy factors that influence the overall cost of credit as determined by the “Committee on Increasing Credit”
  7. Provide alternative investment vehicles by fast-track implementation of Treasury Mobile Direct to offer individuals alternative saving mechanisms besides saving through banks such that individuals can subscribe directly for government securities thus indirectly compelling banks to offer competitive deposit rates; and
  8. Tone down on Government Borrowing to ensure that it does not crowd out private sector and adopt alternative sources of funds such as the Euro Bond while improving Government cash management to ensure that these funds are used only for their intended purposes.

Given that interest rates are as a result of interplay of many structural and policy factors, the solution to high interest rates lies in addressing these same factors rather than capping the interest rates, as Kenya is about to learn.

We would appreciate your comments on this important issue through our email: info@wakainvestments.com

Leave a Reply